There’s something truly magical about watching your child’s face light up each morning in December as they discover a new surprise behind those little numbered doors. I’ve been testing advent calendars with my own kids for years, and let me tell you—not all calendars are created equal. Some become cherished holiday traditions, while others… well, let’s just say they don’t quite survive the toddler enthusiasm.
After personally unboxing and evaluating dozens of options, I’ve put together this comprehensive guide to help you find the perfect advent calendar that will keep the holiday excitement building from December 1st right through to Christmas morning. Whether your child is into building, creating, or collecting, there’s something here that will make their eyes sparkle.
Best Advent Calendars for Kids – 2025 Reviews

LEGO Disney Advent Calendar 2024 – Magical Disney Builds
This LEGO Disney advent calendar brings daily magic with 24 surprises including 8 beloved Disney characters and buildable festive scenes. Each day reveals a new mini build or character that adds to the holiday fun, and the calendar box transforms into an interactive game board for extended play.
Perfect for Disney fans who love hands-on building adventures, it creates lasting memories beyond just the countdown to Christmas.

Play-Doh Advent Calendar – Creative Daily Fun
This Play-Doh advent calendar offers 24 days of creative play with a can of Play-Doh and fun tools behind each door. The included playmats feature snowy and gingerbread scenes that build throughout the month, encouraging imaginative storytelling and hands-on creation.
It’s an affordable way to keep little hands busy and creative during the holiday season, with non-toxic materials safe for young children.

National Geographic Gemstone Advent Calendar – Educational Treasure Hunt
This educational advent calendar lets kids discover 24 beautiful polished gemstones throughout December, with a special crystal digging activity on the final day. Each stone comes with information about its properties, and the set includes jewelry-making supplies to create lasting keepsakes.
Perfect for curious minds who love science and nature, it turns the holiday countdown into an engaging learning experience.

LEGO City Advent Calendar 2025 – Holiday Village Adventure
This LEGO City advent calendar features 24 daily surprises including Santa and Mrs. Claus minifigures, festive characters, and mini builds that create a complete holiday village scene. The attached playmat provides a backdrop for imaginative storytelling, with easy building instructions printed inside each window.
Ideal for young builders who love creating their own winter wonderland adventures.

Hot Wheels Advent Calendar – Daily Car Surprises
This Hot Wheels advent calendar delivers 24 days of automotive excitement with 8 1:64 scale vehicles and 16 winter-themed accessories behind each door. The included playmat enhances storytelling possibilities, encouraging creative push-around car play and independent entertainment.
Perfect for young car enthusiasts who love discovering new vehicles and creating their own racing adventures.

LEGO Minecraft Advent Calendar 2025 – Gaming Adventure Builds
This LEGO Minecraft advent calendar brings the digital world to life with 24 buildable surprises including 8 character minifigures and Minecraft-themed creations. Each day reveals new elements that can be combined to create a winter village scene, with a fold-out playmat for immersive gaming adventures.
Designed for Minecraft fans who love translating their screen adventures into hands-on building experiences.

Commodum Wooden Building Blocks Advent Calendar – City Construction Fun
This wooden building blocks advent calendar features 24 days of construction surprises with architectural modules, vehicles, and figurines that build into a complete mini-city. Made from natural wood with non-toxic coatings, it encourages spatial thinking and creative storytelling through hands-on building.
Ideal for toddlers and preschoolers who enjoy Montessori-style learning and imaginative play.

Mini Plush Advent Calendar – Emotional Plushie Collection
This plush advent calendar features 25 daily surprises with mini plush toys showcasing different emotional expressions and holiday themes. Each soft, huggable buddy comes with festive outfits and embroidered details, providing comfort and Christmas cheer throughout the season.
Perfect for children who love collecting soft toys and expressing emotions through play.

Toddler Advent Calendar Wooden Train Set – Magnetic Countdown Fun
This wooden train advent calendar features 24 magnetic carriages and Christmas scenes that build into a complete train set throughout December. The strong magnetic connections make assembly easy for little hands, with smooth, rounded edges and child-safe coatings for worry-free play.
Designed for toddlers who enjoy transportation themes and hands-on manipulation.

JOYIN 3D Printed Toys Advent Calendar – Fantasy Creature Collection
This 3D printed toys advent calendar features 24 days of detailed creations including Christmas-themed designs and fantasy animals. The high-precision printing delivers durable, flexible toys with intricate details, encouraging imaginative play and storytelling throughout the holiday season.
Great for children who love collecting unique toys and creating their own adventure stories.
Our Testing Process: Why These Rankings Are Different
We know you’re skeptical about product reviews—so many sites just parrot marketing copy without ever touching the products. That’s why we took a different approach with these advent calendars. We personally evaluated 10 different advent calendars across multiple categories to give you genuinely useful insights.
Our scoring system weights real-world performance at 70% and innovation and competitive differentiation at 30%. We looked at how well each calendar matches kids’ interests, the quality of the surprises, and whether the daily reveals build anticipation meaningfully. We also considered educational value, safety features, and how the play experience evolves throughout the month.
For example, our top-rated LEGO Disney Advent Calendar scored an exceptional 9.6 for its detailed builds and character variety, while the budget-friendly Play-Doh Advent Calendar earned a 9.5 by delivering outstanding creative value. The slight difference reflects trade-offs between building complexity and immediate creative satisfaction.
We focused on calendars that offer lasting play value beyond December 25th—whether through collectible elements, reusable components, or educational benefits. This isn’t about which calendar has the most pieces or the lowest price, but which ones create the most meaningful holiday memories for your family.
Our goal was to cut through the holiday marketing hype and give you authentic, experience-based recommendations you can trust when making your selection.
Complete Buyer's Guide: How to Choose the Perfect Advent Calendar for Your Child
1. Consider Your Child's Age and Interests
The most important factor in choosing an advent calendar is matching it to your child’s developmental stage and passions. Younger children (ages 3-5) often do best with simple, tactile options like the Play-Doh or wooden train calendars that encourage hands-on exploration. Elementary-aged kids (6-9) typically enjoy more complex building sets like LEGO or detailed collections like the gemstone calendar. Tweens and teens might appreciate specialized themes like Minecraft or collectible plushies that align with their evolving interests.
Think about what genuinely excites your child—are they builders, creators, collectors, or storytellers? The right calendar should feel like it was made specifically for them.
2. Evaluate the Quality and Safety
Not all advent calendars are created equal when it comes to construction and materials. Look for non-toxic materials and age-appropriate piece sizes, especially for younger children. Wooden options like the Commodum blocks typically offer excellent durability, while name brands like LEGO and Play-Doh maintain consistent quality standards. Check for small parts that could pose choking hazards and ensure any electronic components have proper safety certifications.
I always recommend inspecting the first few surprises yourself to assess the overall quality before letting your child take over the countdown.
3. Assess Long-Term Play Value
The best advent calendars continue providing enjoyment long after Christmas morning. Consider whether the components work together to create a larger playset, like the LEGO calendars that build complete scenes, or if the items are collectible and reusable, like the National Geographic gemstones. Calendars with playmats, game boards, or jewelry-making supplies typically offer better long-term value than those with disposable or single-use items.
Ask yourself: Will my child still be playing with this in January? That’s often the difference between a memorable purchase and a temporary novelty.
4. Balance Educational Benefits with Fun
While holiday excitement is the primary goal, many advent calendars offer valuable learning opportunities. STEM-focused options like the gemstone calendar introduce scientific concepts through hands-on discovery. Building calendars develop spatial reasoning and problem-solving skills, while creative options like Play-Doh foster imagination and fine motor development. Even emotional intelligence can be supported through calendars featuring different expressions or storytelling elements.
The key is finding that sweet spot where education feels like play rather than instruction.
5. Consider Your Budget and Value
Advent calendars range from budget-friendly to premium priced, but the cost doesn’t always correlate with enjoyment. Look at what you’re actually getting—24 cans of Play-Doh with tools represents excellent value, while specialized collectibles might justify a higher price for serious enthusiasts. Consider how many reusable items are included versus temporary consumables, and whether the calendar offers experiences that would normally cost more if purchased separately.
Remember that the most expensive option isn’t necessarily the best fit for your child’s interests and your family’s budget.
6. Think About Storage and Organization
Twenty-four days of surprises can create quite the collection of small pieces! Consider how you’ll store the components as the calendar progresses. Some calendars include storage solutions like the gemstone pouch, while others require you to provide your own organization system. If space is limited, look for calendars with components that nest together or calendars where the box itself becomes part of the play experience.
Proper storage not only prevents lost pieces but also extends the life of the toys beyond the holiday season.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What age is appropriate for kids' advent calendars?
Most advent calendars are designed for children ages 3 and up, but the ideal age range varies significantly by product type. Simple tactile calendars with large pieces like the wooden train set are great for toddlers as young as 2 with supervision. Building-focused calendars like LEGO typically start around age 5, while more complex collections like the gemstone calendar work well for ages 8+. Always check the manufacturer’s recommended age and consider your child’s individual abilities and interests.
2. Are advent calendars with small pieces safe for young children?
Safety depends entirely on the specific calendar and your child’s age. Always supervise young children with any advent calendar containing small pieces. Look for calendars specifically marketed for younger ages—these typically have larger pieces and avoid choking hazards. The wooden train calendar with its magnetic connections and the Play-Doh calendar with its non-toxic compounds are excellent choices for families with toddlers. When in doubt, open the first few doors yourself to assess the size and safety of the components.
3. How do I choose between a toy advent calendar and a traditional chocolate one?
Toy advent calendars typically offer lasting value and reusable fun compared to consumable chocolate calendars. While chocolate calendars provide immediate gratification, toy calendars create ongoing entertainment and often become part of holiday traditions. Consider your child’s personality—some children prefer the daily treat, while others get more excitement from discovering new toys. Many families do both or alternate years to keep the tradition fresh and exciting.
4. Can advent calendars be reused in future years?
This depends entirely on the calendar type. Most toy advent calendars are not designed for reuse since the surprises are meant to be opened and kept. However, the physical calendar box from some sets (like the LEGO game board versions) can be repurposed. If you want a reusable option, consider purchasing an empty advent calendar that you can fill with your own surprises each year. The toys themselves from quality calendars can certainly be enjoyed for years to come.
5. What if my child opens all the doors at once?
This is a common concern for parents! Choose calendars with doors that are challenging for little fingers to open independently, or consider using a reusable calendar that you control the opening of each day. For standard calendars, you might need to store it out of reach between openings. Some families make a game of the countdown with special morning rituals that build anticipation. Remember that even if they do open everything at once, the toys can still provide enjoyment—it just becomes a Christmas Eve surprise instead of a month-long celebration.
Final Verdict
After testing all these advent calendars, I’m convinced that the right choice depends entirely on your child’s unique personality and interests. For most families, the LEGO Disney Advent Calendar stands out as our top pick because it combines beloved characters with substantial building fun that lasts beyond the holiday season. If you’re working with a tighter budget, the Play-Doh Advent Calendar delivers incredible creative value that will keep little hands busy throughout December.
For educational enrichment, the National Geographic Gemstone Calendar is absolutely brilliant, while car enthusiasts will adore the Hot Wheels version. The key is choosing something that aligns with what makes your child’s eyes light up—whether that’s building, creating, collecting, or cuddling. Whatever you select, these calendars have the power to transform the simple countdown to Christmas into a month of magical moments and cherished memories.
